Restoring Trust in Higher Education: Accountability and the Path Forward
Published 27 November 2024
(In Ep #0 of the Professionall Pathways Podcast | Cal’s Journey into Teacher Education)
“Since I was in college, I think what has changed the most in our higher education systems has been this noticeable increase in the levels of public doubt about the value of higher education. In my generation alone we were told as kids that having a college degree was mandatory and that it would set you up for a successful and prosperous life. But then as we reached adulthood, many have seen that a degree is just not as powerful as it once was in the workplace for many professions. Especially with more recent updates like the number of protests on campuses related to the schools that are invested in war enterprises. I think ultimately having a higher level of accountability for higher education systems will be a good thing.”
Higher education has long been heralded as a gateway to opportunity, prosperity, and personal growth. Yet, in recent decades, a palpable decline in public trust has emerged. This skepticism stems from concerns about rising tuition costs, unclear career outcomes, and ethical questions surrounding institutional investments and policies. While public trust is eroding, there is an opportunity to address these challenges and rebuild confidence in the transformative power of higher education.
The Roots of Public Skepticism
The decline in public trust has multifaceted origins. Economic factors are significant–—rising tuition costs have left many graduates burdened with debt while facing a competitive job market. A 2022 report by the Pew Research Center highlighted that 57% of Americans believe colleges and universities prioritize profits over the education of their students (Brown, 2022). This perception can erode faith in institutions as champions of opportunity.
Additionally, recent controversies around ethical governance have compounded these doubts. For instance, public scrutiny has intensified regarding universities investing in industries like fossil fuels or defense enterprises, raising questions about whether institutional actions align with societal and student values. These issues suggest a gap between institutional priorities and public expectations.
The Role of Accountability
Accountability is central to restoring trust in higher education. Institutions that actively address public concerns, whether by revising tuition structures, improving transparency in decision-making, or aligning values with actions, can begin to rebuild their reputations. Students, parents, and policymakers increasingly seek data-driven assurances that higher education delivers on its promises. Research suggests that when universities implement clear metrics for success—–such as graduate employability rates, ethical investment strategies, and student satisfaction scores—–they foster greater public confidence (Marginson, 2019).
Reimagining Higher Education
The current sentiments provide an opportunity to reshape higher education systems to better serve the needs of students and society. The shift could involve:
Incorporating Flexible Learning Paths: Expanding nontraditional options such as online degrees and vocational training can make education more accessible and adaptable to diverse student needs.
Promoting Ethical Leadership: Universities must align investments and policies with socially responsible practices to demonstrate a commitment to societal well-being.
Prioritizing Career Readiness: Strengthening partnerships with industries to provide internships and career services ensures students see a direct link between their education and employment prospects.
Amplifying Student Voices: Transparent governance that includes student input in key decisions can restore confidence in institutions as advocates for their stakeholders.
Enhancing Community Engagement: Universities can focus on serving local communities through outreach programs and public benefits, reinforcing their roles as essential social institutions.
Practical Tips to Rebuild Trust
Be Transparent: Share data on tuition costs, graduate success rates, and institutional policies to foster public understanding.
Support Students Holistically: Address financial intelligence, mental health, and career development needs to demonstrate a student-centered approach.
Advocate for Affordability: Work to reduce tuition costs or provide alternative pathways for students from underprivileged backgrounds.
Engage the Public: Host community forums to discuss concerns and actively involve stakeholders in institutional planning.
Ensure Ethical Practices: Conduct regular reviews of investments and policies to align with public expectations and values.
Discussion Question
How can higher education institutions actively demonstrate accountability and rebuild trust with their stakeholders in a rapidly changing societal landscape?
Related Posts
-
Brown, A. (2022). Public trust in higher education: A growing divide. Pew Research Center. Retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/10/13/public-trust-in-higher-education/
Marginson, S. (2019). Higher education and the common good. Studies in Higher Education, 44(7), 1-15. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2019.1573161
